Blog

CRPS After a Car Accident in New York: Signs and Your Rights

By Matt Segal

Hand therapist treating a patient with nerve pain in the hand after a car accident

TL;DR: CRPS after a car accident is a nerve pain condition that can follow a broken wrist, a sprained ankle, or surgery from the crash, causing burning pain, swelling, and skin changes far worse than the original injury. Early treatment gives you the best chance to recover. In New York, CRPS can support an injury claim, but insurers often call the pain exaggerated, so steady treatment and careful medical records decide most of these cases.

As of 2026, a person in New York who develops complex regional pain syndrome, often called CRPS, after a car accident may be able to sue the at fault driver for pain and suffering if they can show the condition is a serious injury under state law. CRPS used to be called RSD, or reflex sympathetic dystrophy, and many doctors and insurance forms still use that name. The condition is real, it is often missed, and it is one of the most disputed injuries in car accident cases.

According to the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke, more than 90 percent of CRPS cases follow an injury to the arm or leg, and fractures are the most common trigger. Car crashes cause exactly those injuries. A driver braces against the steering wheel and breaks a wrist. A knee slams into the dashboard. A foot jammed on the brake pedal twists the ankle. Any of these can be the start.

What Is CRPS and How Can a Car Accident Cause It?

CRPS is a condition where the nerves and the body's pain system overreact after an injury, so pain stays intense and spreads long after the original injury should have healed. A car accident can cause CRPS when it injures an arm, hand, leg, or foot, especially through a fracture, a sprain, a crush injury, or the surgery and casting that follow.

Doctors describe two types. The symptoms are the same in both.

  • CRPS Type 1, formerly called RSD, is diagnosed when doctors cannot point to one specific damaged nerve.

  • CRPS Type 2, formerly called causalgia, is diagnosed when a specific nerve injury is found.

CRPS can happen at any age, but NINDS reports it peaks around age 40 and is more common in women. That puts working adults squarely in the group most affected.

What Are the Warning Signs of CRPS After a Crash?

The main warning sign of CRPS after a crash is pain that is much worse than the injury should cause and that does not fade as the injury heals. Many people first notice it when a cast comes off or weeks after surgery. Other signs include the following.

  • Burning, stabbing, or deep aching pain in the arm, hand, leg, or foot

  • Pain from light touch, a bedsheet, a breeze, or clothing against the skin

  • Swelling that comes and goes

  • Skin that turns red, blue, purple, or blotchy

  • One limb that feels much warmer or colder than the other

  • Unusual sweating, or skin that looks shiny or thin

  • Changes in how hair or nails grow on that limb

  • Stiff joints and weakness that make gripping or walking hard

Most people do not have every symptom. If you have several, tell your doctor and use the words out of proportion to describe the pain. That phrase matters because it is part of how CRPS is diagnosed.

With CRPS, the injury can heal while the pain keeps getting worse.

How Is CRPS Diagnosed After a Car Accident?

CRPS after a car accident is diagnosed through a careful exam, not one single test. Most doctors use a checklist called the Budapest Criteria, which looks for pain out of proportion to the injury plus signs in four areas. Those areas are sensation, skin temperature and color, sweating and swelling, and movement or changes in hair, nails, and skin.

Doctors may also order tests that support the diagnosis or rule out other problems.

Test What it can show
Three phase bone scan Changes in the bones near the painful joints
Thermography A temperature difference between the injured limb and the healthy one
Sweat testing Abnormal sweating in the affected area
Nerve studies, MRI, or ultrasound Nerve damage or other injuries that could explain the pain
X rays Bone thinning in the affected limb over time

A normal X ray or MRI does not mean you do not have CRPS. It is a clinical diagnosis. What matters most is that a doctor examines you more than once and writes down what they see at each visit, such as swelling, color change, temperature difference, and how far you can move.

How Is CRPS Treated, and Does Early Treatment Matter?

Initial treatment matters a great deal with CRPS, because NINDS reports that many early or mild cases improve, and treatment works best when it starts soon after symptoms appear. Treatment usually combines several approaches.

  • Physical and occupational therapy, which NINDS calls the most important treatment, to keep the limb moving and retrain how the brain reads pain signals

  • Medications for nerve pain, inflammation, and sleep

  • Nerve blocks, injections that calm the nerves in the affected area

  • Counseling or pain psychology because long term pain affects sleep, mood, and family life

  • Spinal cord stimulation and other implanted devices for severe cases that do not respond to other care

Many people improve over months to a few years. A smaller group lives with lasting pain and disability despite treatment. That uncertainty is one reason a CRPS case should not be settled until doctors have a clear picture of what the future looks like.

Does CRPS Count as a Serious Injury Under New York Law?

CRPS can count as a serious injury under New York law, but it usually has to be proven through objective medical evidence showing it significantly or permanently limits how you use a body part or body system. New York's no fault system pays medical bills and some lost wages for people hurt in car crashes. To sue the at fault driver for pain and suffering, you must first show a serious injury under Insurance Law 5102(d).

CRPS cases most often rely on these categories.

  • Permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member

  • Significant limitation of use of a body function or system

  • Permanent loss of use, in the most severe cases

  • Fracture, when the crash also broke a bone

The 2026 law changed this in an important way. For lawsuits filed on or after May 26, 2026, New York removed the category that covered injuries keeping you from almost all normal activities for 90 of the first 180 days. Many CRPS claims used that category in the past, especially early on, before a doctor could say the condition was permanent. Now the medical record has to show a significant or permanent limitation, measured and tied to the crash.

Why Do Insurance Companies Push Back on CRPS Claims?

Insurance companies push back on CRPS claims because the pain is hard to see on a scan, and that makes it easy to argue the pain is exaggerated or caused by something else. These are the arguments people hear most.

Myth: If the X ray is normal, the pain is not real.

Fact: CRPS often does not show up on standard imaging. Doctors diagnose it by exam. Thermography, bone scans, and measured changes in swelling and range of motion can give objective support.

Myth: The insurance doctor said I am fine, so I have no case.

Fact: Insurers send people to exams with doctors they choose, sometimes months after symptoms started, when signs may come and go. Your treating doctors, who see you over time, often carry more weight when their records are detailed.

Myth: Taking a break from therapy will not matter.

Fact: Gaps in treatment are one of the first things insurers use to argue the pain is not serious or was not caused by the crash. If cost or no fault denials are stopping your care, say so in writing so the reason is on record.

Myth: Being partly at fault does not affect a car accident claim.

Fact: Under New York's 2026 change, in most car accident lawsuits filed on or after May 26, 2026, you can be barred from recovering if a jury finds you more at fault than the driver you are suing. If you share less fault, your recovery is reduced by your share. Proof of how the crash happened matters more now than it used to.

What Should You Do If You Think You Have CRPS After a Car Accident?

If you think you have CRPS after a car accident, the most important steps are getting the right specialist and building a steady medical record from the start.

  1. Tell your doctor right away if pain is getting worse instead of better and describe it as out of proportion to the injury.

  2. Ask for a referral to a pain management doctor or neurologist who has experience with CRPS.

  3. Photograph changes in skin color, swelling, and sweating when they happen, since these signs can come and go before an exam.

  4. Keep a pain journal with dates, pain levels, what triggers flares, and tasks you can no longer do.

  5. Go to every appointment and finish your therapy plan or write down why you could not.

  6. File your no fault application on time, generally within 30 days of the crash, and keep copies of every bill and denial letter.

  7. Be careful what you sign and do not give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer before getting advice.

How Long Do You Have to File a CRPS Claim in New York?

Most CRPS claims from a car accident in New York must be filed in court within three years of the crash, but no fault and city deadlines come much sooner.

Deadline Time limit
No fault benefits application Generally 30 days from the crash
Notice of claim if a city vehicle or city road was involved 90 days from the crash
Lawsuit against the City of New York 1 year and 90 days from the crash
Lawsuit against a private driver or company 3 years from the crash (CPLR 214)

CRPS often is not diagnosed until months after the crash. The legal clock still starts on the day of the accident, not the day of the diagnosis.

When Should You Talk to a Lawyer About CRPS After a Car Accident?

You should talk to a lawyer about CRPS after a car accident as soon as a doctor suspects the condition, because the medical record built in those first months will decide whether you can meet New York's serious injury rules.

Picture a home health aide in the Bronx who is rear ended on the Bruckner Expressway. She braces against the steering wheel and breaks her wrist. Six weeks later the cast comes off, but her hand is swollen, purple, and so sensitive she cannot stand a sleeve touching it. She cannot lift her clients, button a coat, or hold a coffee cup. The other driver's insurer says the fracture healed on schedule. Her case depends on doctors who document what is happening to her hand at every visit.

Segal Law Firm, based in Manhattan, represents people across Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, Staten Island, and Manhattan who are living with CRPS and other lasting injuries after car accidents. Segal can help you connect with the right care, keep your medical record complete, meet the serious injury rules that took effect in 2026, and count future treatment such as nerve blocks or spinal cord stimulation before any settlement is discussed.

Talk to Segal About Your CRPS Claim

If you are living with burning pain, swelling, or skin changes after a car accident, call Segal Law Firm at (646) 810-3337 or request a Free Case Evaluation on our contact page. If you would rather get to know the firm first, take a few minutes to get to know Segal in five minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a car accident cause CRPS?

A car accident can cause CRPS when it injures an arm, hand, leg, or foot. Fractures, especially wrist fractures, are the most common trigger, but sprains, crush injuries, and surgery after a crash can also lead to CRPS.

Is CRPS the same as RSD?

CRPS and RSD refer to the same condition. RSD, or reflex sympathetic dystrophy, is the older name for what doctors now call CRPS Type 1, when no single damaged nerve is identified.

How long after a car accident can CRPS start?

CRPS often starts within weeks of a car accident injury and is commonly noticed when a cast comes off or during recovery from surgery. A diagnosis can take months, which is why reporting worsening pain early matters.

Does CRPS meet New York's serious injury threshold?

CRPS can meet New York's serious injury threshold when objective medical evidence shows it permanently or significantly limits the use of a limb or body system. For lawsuits filed on or after May 26, 2026, the 90 of 180 day category is no longer available.

What can a CRPS claim recover after a car accident?

A CRPS claim after a car accident can recover medical costs beyond no fault benefits, future treatment such as nerve blocks or spinal cord stimulation, lost wages and earning power, and pain and suffering when the serious injury threshold is met.

Keep Reading

Two related guides cover the questions that usually come next: what CRPS is and the symptoms to watch for and whether CRPS gets worse over time.

Every case turns on its own facts. Tell us what happened in a free case evaluation with Segal Law Firm. There is no fee unless we win.

One last thing before you go. Accidents never happen at a convenient time, so take seven seconds to save Segal in your phone and our number is already there when you need it.

Related Articles

Get new articles like this by email

Join our list for plain-English New York injury law updates, new case results, and practical guidance from Matt Segal.

By subscribing you agree to receive emails from Segal Law Firm. Unsubscribe anytime.